Malanova (Italian)

This slow-paced film thoughtfully explores a gay couple at a crossroads while addressing the topic of HIV, which remains as significant today as it was in the past. Unfortunately, despite the good intentions behind the project, the filmmakers lacked sufficient story material, resulting in many quiet moments with little action. The film is visually stunning, but I wish there had been more depth to the narrative.

Matteo and Riccardo are celebrating six months together when they embark on a hike. During the outing, Matteo experiences an episode of illness, revealing that he is HIV-positive. Surprisingly, Riccardo chooses to stay and offers his support. However, despite Matteo urging him to get tested, Riccardo hesitates, likely out of fear of discovering his own status. Meanwhile, Matteo grapples with uncertainty regarding his treatment options. When Matteo unexpectedly visits Enzo, Riccardo’s initial suspicion gives way to understanding when he learns that Enzo is Matteo’s uncle. Enzo provides both men with insight into their feelings and offers perspective on managing the illness and their relationship, drawing from his own experiences over the years. He shares how different things were for lovers in the ’80s, especially those affected by HIV.

It seems the filmmaker aimed to spark a conversation around this topic, as HIV is not widely discussed today despite medical advancements. While the treatment has improved and the illness can be managed, the filmmakers missed the mark in conveying this message effectively. Most of the dialogue revolves around Enzo’s experiences from the past. Even though Riccardo doesn’t abandon Matteo upon learning his status and understands that with an undetectable viral load he is safe, he still fears knowing his own status.

The film features many tender and passionate scenes between the two actors, who deliver commendable performances. However, overall, I felt underwhelmed and had anticipated much more. There’s a notable absence of conflict or drama, despite the potential of the subject matter.